This old-fashioned cinnamon candy comes straight from my grandma’s 1940s cookbook and only needs 5 simple ingredients. It’s mild and buttery with a warm brown sugar flavor, so think Werther’s with a hint of cinnamon, not Red Hots! It’s easy enough for first-time candy makers and perfect for filling Christmas tins and stockings.
Place all ingredients in a medium saucepan. Stir to combine.
Boil to 275°-280° F, stirring constantly.
Immediately pour onto prepared cookie sheet.
Once cooled, break into small pieces.
Notes
Helpful Tipsmeter. These are the tips I wish I’d known before my first batch!
Test your candy thermometer first. Clip it into a pot of boiling water. It should read 212°F at sea level. If it reads a few degrees off, adjust your target temperature by that same amount. At higher elevations, water boils at a lower temperature, so subtract about 1°F for every 500 feet above sea level.
Get your pan ready before you start. Grease your cookie sheet with butter or line it with parchment before you turn on the stove. Once the candy hits 275 to 280°F, you need to pour it right away. There’s no time to hunt for a pan!
Use a heavy-bottomed saucepan. A thicker pan heats more evenly, so the sugar is less likely to scorch on the bottom. A medium size gives the mixture room to bubble up without boiling over.
Keep the thermometer in the candy, not on the pan. The tip should sit in the bubbling mixture without touching the bottom of the pot. If it touches the bottom, you’ll get a reading that’s too hot and take the candy off the stove too soon.
Stir the whole time. Grandma’s recipe says to stir constantly, and it’s good advice with butter and cinnamon in the pot. Stirring keeps the cinnamon from settling and burning on the bottom.
Brush down the sides of the pot. If you see sugar crystals forming on the sides, brush them down with a pastry brush dipped in water. Stray crystals can fall back in and make the whole batch grainy.
Don’t scrape the pot when you pour. Pour the candy onto the sheet and leave the last bit in the pan. The sugar stuck to the sides is the most likely to be grainy.
No candy thermometer? Try the cold water test. Drop a little of the hot mixture into a glass of very cold water. At the soft-crack stage, it forms threads that are firm but still bend a little before they break.
Make it on a dry day. Humidity is candy’s worst enemy and can leave it sticky. Save your candy making for a dry day, and store the pieces in an airtight container right away.
Break it two ways. For neater pieces, score the candy with a buttered knife while it’s still warm. For a rustic look, let it cool all the way, put it in a zip-top bag, and tap it with a rolling pin. My kids love doing this part!
Be careful with hot sugar. Candy at 280°F can cause serious burns, so keep little ones back while you’re cooking and pouring. Let them help with breaking it into pieces once it’s cool.
Clean up the easy way. Fill the pot with water and bring it to a boil. The hardened candy melts right off.